Recommending Someone Their First Reward Credit Card - Running with Miles
Credit Cards

Recommending Someone Their First Reward Credit Card

Advertiser Disclosure

The other day, a friend of mine had asked me if I would recommend a rewards credit card for her aunt (we’ll call her Debbie). Debbie was looking to do more traveling and wanted to earn rewards to make it more affordable. She wanted to earn miles, points, or cash back, but wasn’t sure which one would work best for her. Being that I love credit cards and their rewards, how could I say no? 🙂

There are many reward credit cards on the market. Some receive more publicity than others, but everyone’s goals are different. It is always a fun challenge to recommend a card to someone looking to travel for less money!

So many options!

So many options!

I reached out and introduced myself to Debbie, letting her know I’d be more than happy to help her pick a credit card that she would like to earn rewards. After asking a few basic questions:

  1. What is your credit score?
    • Anyone playing the points game should ideally have a credit score over 700.
  2. What are your traveling goals?
    • I think this is where most people get caught up in the “best card” talk from friends/bloggers. The best card is what works best for you.
    • You should always have a goal in mind when applying for reward credit cards. It is always best to have a goal in mind and work backwards.
  3. What airlines does she typically fly?
    • I don’t want to recommend a card to someone with an airline or hotel chain they do not use. That would be a complete waste.
  4. Does she want easiest redemption, or is she willing to learn some basics about award availability?
    • Let’s be honest, it can be frustrating to search for an award seat on an airline, just to see it either isn’t available, or lack of saver awards.
    • Some airlines are straightforward (Southwest, Jetblue), but if you want to get the most out of other programs, you should learn some basics about partners and award charts. 
    • Not everyone wants to take the time to learn those things, that is something I have learned along the way when people ask me questions.
Screenshot 2016-09-04 at 2.49.54 PM

Have a destination in mind, then figure out which points will get you there!

I asked a few other questions, but I think these are questions each person should ask themselves when starting out in the points game (or anytime you get a new credit card). 

Debbie was purchasing a ticket for an international trip (it would be about $1500) and she would be out of the country for about 3 weeks. I kept that in mind, because a card with a foreign transaction fee would be a terrible choice. 

She is based out Boston and has a few options for airlines. I started thinking about the airlines she has access to, such as United, Jetblue, Southwest, Delta, and others. She doesn’t travel too often now, but would like to start. She also isn’t partial to a particular airline.

Debbie was also looking for a card with a nice bonus (aren’t we all 🙂 ). The bonus would be used for a future trip, since she was ready to pay for her current trip.

She also wasn’t interested in opening a lot of cards, but wanted a card she could use for everyday spending and earn valuable rewards.

Before we started digging deeper into what she wanted, I had some options in my head already, such as the Chase Sapphire Preferred, possibly the Chase Sapphire Reserve (for someone new $450 is a hefty fee to pay, even though it is worth it for year 1 IMO), and a few others.

Those possible recommendations went out the window when she mentioned she spends about $500 per month on her credit cards.

Based on her average spend, she would not hit the minimum spending requirement for either of the Chase cards. Which is pefectly fine, but I don’t want to encourage overspending to earn points. That’s how people get into trouble!

She also wasn’t interested in learning the award charts at this time. The more I questions I asked, the clearer things became. 

I started to summarize the key points for Debbie:
  • Big Bonus
  • No Foreign Transaction fees
  • In 3 months, she can realistically hit a $3,000 spend limit (since $1500 would be her airline ticket cost, plus $500 per month)
  • Wanted easy redemptions, and was not interested in learning award charts.
  • Wasn’t partial to any one airline
  • Had credit score over 700 to play the game
  • Goals were to earn points to use for future redemption on travel
  • She wasn’t looking to churn credit cards
  • She will earn miles on the tickets she purchases.

There were 2 cards that came to my mind when I started narrowing down options. They were the Barclay Arrival Plus and the Capital One Venture card.

Screenshot 2016-09-04 at 9.37.57 AM

Why did these 2 cards pop into my mind?

These 2 card hit all the big points for Debbie.

  • The bonuses are large, worth $460 ($483 for Arrival Plus),after hitting the $3,000 requirement. She will hit this minimum with her upcoming and average spending
  • These cards essentially make you a free agent, because you can book on any airline, at anytime. No need to worry about award availability.
  • No Foreign Transaction Fees
  • Easy redemptions as she just uses the points to erase the charges.
  • Had proper credit score to get the cards
  • Can use the points for a future redemption

The downside to these cards would be that you don’t necessarily get the same value out of flexible point cards. With transferring points to partners, it is possible to exceed 2 cents per point value. That said, 2% back isn’t a bad earning rate (it should be the minimum you earn).

These 2 cards fit the bill for Debbie, but there was one key factor that separated one of the cards from the other.

What card did I end up recommending?

Although the Barclay Arrival Plus, gives you 5% back on your redemptions, meaning you earn 2.1% back vs the 2% back on the Capital One Venture. To me that amount is small enough, that it is nice, but not a must have piece.

I recommended the Capital One Venture card over the Barclay Arrival Plus. It came down to the minumum amount needed to redeem your miles.

Capital One doesn’t have a minimum redemption amount!  The Arrival Plus, you have a minimum redemption of 10,000 points ($100). I find it harder to recommend the Arrival Plus, since there are lots of travel cost that are below $100.

The Capital One Venture card also has a lower annual fee ($59) compared to the Barclay Arrival Plus ($89), but both are waived for year 1.

Debbie wasn’t interested in churning cards, the fact Capital One pulls from all 3 bureaus, doesn’t change my recommendation. 

The next day, Debbie let me know she had applied and was approved for the Capital One Venture card with a nice credit limit. Happy travels Debbie and welcome to the world of traveling for less! 

Do you agree with my recommendation for Debbie? What would you have recommended for her?  

Don’t forget to Like me on Facebook, or Follow me on Twitter. If you have questions, comments or would like a topic, leave a comment. Thank you for reading!

Editorial Note - Opinions expressed here are author's alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, hotel, airline, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included within the post.

Some of the links on this site are affiliate links that will support this site. Thank you for your support.

About the author

Dustin

After completing 6 years of pharmacy school, I finally had the time to travel. I started investigating ways to travel for less and when I redeemed my first award flight for my honeymoon, I knew I was hooked! Fast forward a couple of years and places I had never dreamed of visiting like Budapest, Honolulu, Bermuda and many other places where all within my reach, and for little to no money out of my pocket. Now, I have collected well over a million points and miles, and try to help people travel for less on their wallet.

9 Comments

  • Spending $500 a month at 2% would be $120 a year, so it almost seems to be a minor factor compared to the bonus. Given that I would have looked into pushing it for the Chase Sapphire Reserve. The required spend would be $1K more, but the bonus would be two to three times the Venture card. That could be some Walmart gift cards, or whatever, to shift some spend from later to now.

    This is assuming her scores were good enough and she could pay the statements on time. Your choice is a good safe one, but I would have at least seen if she was comfortable with pushing it just a bit.

      • Hi Carl,

        Thanks for reading! She didn’t feel comfortable with the $4k spend. I did mention it, but not everyone is comfortable with shift spending, etc. not overspending for points is key.

        The bonus on the CSR is larger, but given she didn’t want to get into the award charts and no way the CSR would be a long term keeper.

        Again, thanks for reading, I appreciate the comment!

        • With her fairly small spend it will take a while to get much more even at 2% (especially if she pays an AF later). Something tells me she’ll take the plunge again later when she sees the small accumulation, rather than grinding it out on spend alone.

  • How about Chase IHG? Not great return on spend, but with $500/mo, she won’t be racking up crazy points regardless. With a decent sign up bonus, 1 free night at any IHG hotel (including some nights Intercontinentals), plus no forex fee, I think it might be a nice match for her. I’ve also gotten some nice room upgrades once in a while due to status I received through this card.

    • Thanks for the comment IKC!

      Airfare was more of a concern.

      I agree with you IHG card is a great card, but getting a brand specific card probably isn’t best as your first card. Not a lot of flexibility, as far as devaluation.

      Thanks for reading!

  • Not a bad recommendation, though I would’ve probably pushed her to just get the Citi 2% cash back card and a second no foreign transaction fee card that’s either (1) worth the annual fee, since with her low spend she won’t be redeeming for anything good or anything that’s worth an annual fee, or (2) has no ftfs. (This is assuming she doesn’t already have a cc with no ftf.) I agree with the IHG recommendation above.

    But she sounds like someone who doesn’t want to play the game, so simpler is better, and I’m worried that annual fee is just going to be a total waste for her.

    • for my second option, I meant a no annual fee card with no foreign transaction fees. Cap one has them and I assume Citi and Chase and others do now…

      • Hey A,

        Thanks for the comment.

        At a low spend, yes I agree it’ll take time to earn a lot. The Citi DC is a great option, but lack of a bonus. $460 would take her almost 4 years of spending to earn!

        As fas as No fee FTF, I’m don’t believe Chase or Citi has one. I could be wrong on that though.

        Thanks for the comment!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Enter your e-mail address to receive blog updates!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

%d bloggers like this: