Deals The Basics

An Open-Box Experience That Went Bad & What Best Buy Did About It

best buy open-box
Written by Charlie

Buying open-box items can save you a lot of money and sometimes even still give you the warranty! Here is what happened with one open-box buy that went bad.

If you read about some of the deals I post here, I absolutely love the open-box items from some retailers. Not all of them are ones I would trust but there are a few that I have bought from (some on a regular basis!) that I absolutely trust and find no problems with whatsoever.

A Bad Open-Box Experience


Why Buy Open-Box

The great thing about open-box electronics is that you can get an item that may have been just opened and then returned for a significant discount. Depending on the store representative that accepted the return, the discount could be as high as 20% off for some items, plus (depending on the store) it still may be eligible for the manufacturer warranty! With the discounts and warranty, there is almost no reason to not look for open-box items when shopping for something!

In all the years of my open-box shopping, I have had almost a perfect record in regards to quality of the items. But, that took a big twist with a recent purchase. I am a bit of a tech guy and love getting gear open-box, using it for a while, selling it at cost or for profit, and getting something else.

What Happened With This Open-Box Order

I did this recently with a camera and got a great deal on the new camera I wanted to use for a while. I purchased it from Best Buy and had to wait a couple of weeks to get it as my family was bringing it to me. The big day came when I got it and was eager to hook up a couple of great lenses to it to try it out myself.

Of course, I had to charge the battery first and while it was charging, I was looking around this nice, new camera. It was then that I discovered it was missing a port that this model has on it. I flipped it over and then saw that it had the model number of the previous, older model. The two models are identical in form and size so this is why it was not caught before.

What had likely happened is that someone purchased it from Best Buy, put their older model camera in the newer model box, and returned it. Worst case, they get caught and apologize based on the similarities. Best case, they have gotten the new camera for free and cheated Best Buy.

And that is what happened. The loser at this point? The new buyer who opened the sealed box and found the wrong camera in it and had to convince Best Buy that it was their fault – that person was me. The camera had been ordered online so it was sent to me by mail and I did not get a chance to check it in store.

What Best Buy Did About It

I called Best Buy and explained everything. I was really hoping that Best Buy would believe my account and that I would not get stuck with this older model. Fortunately, I had a wonderful customer service person that believed me and even went ahead and cleared it with a supervisor to send me another one – before I even sent this one back in! This would let my discounts and credits stay intact and I would not have to deal with it all over again. Great job, Best Buy, in helping out the customer!

So what happens with this camera that goes back? It is likely not possible to even go back to the customer that returned it as they have no proof that it was the customer and not someone in the Best Buy service chain that replaced the camera (I am not saying it was a Best Buy employee, just explaining why it would be difficult to put it on the customer). They will likely either sell it on their outlet at a bigger discount than it would go for otherwise (since it is in the wrong box).

Tips for Buying Open-Box


Consider paying a bit more for certified

I remember hearing stories of how people used to buy iPads, replace the iPad in the box with paper notebooks, shrink wrap it and return it for a refund. That is difficult for the end-user since they are buying a “new” item and they would have a hard time proving that it was not their fault.

In-Store: What you should do if buying an open-box item is to open it right in the store and check it out. This is good even if this had not happened to me. Whenever I buy an open-box item in the store, I always open it in front of store personnel in case there are problems with it.

Online: If you purchase it online, it makes it a little more difficult. If it is a high dollar item, I would suggest grabbing your smartphone (or some other camera) and video the whole experience of opening the box (which would be sealed with their tamper-proof tape). This way, if there is something wrong with it, you have video proof that it was not on you. Fortunately, I am able to return this but I should have thought of that myself beforehand!

Another thing you could do is to pay a few dollars more (if available) for a Geek Squad-certified open-box as that has been checked over by their tech team and any different item would be spotted. This way, you are still able to get a good deal but have the extra assurance that your item will be what you ordered and in good shape.

Credit Card: Depending on the credit card you use, there could also be some buyer’s protection if something goes really bad as well. If you have proof and the store will not believe you, you could always take it up with the credit card company and let them deal with it. Credit card protection is just one more reason to use a credit card instead of cash when making purchases!


I have had nothing but great experiences with Best Buy and buying open-box items. It has saved me thousands of dollars over the years and even allowed me to continually trade up each year without paying anything extra! Will I keep buying open-box? Absolutely! But, I will take some extra measures to make sure something like this does not stick me with a big problem and a loss of money. Hopefully, this will help you as well!

Some of the links on Running with Miles are affiliate links that pay a commission if a purchase is made. Running with Miles is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

About the author


Charlie has been an avid traveler and runner for many years. He has run in marathons around the world for less than it would cost to travel to the next town - all as a result of collecting and using miles and points. Over the years, he has flown hundreds of thousands of miles and collected millions of miles and points.
Now he uses this experience and knowledge to help others through Running with Miles.


  • Hi Charlie,

    I too bought an open box camera at Best Buy and was very satisfied with the result. I opened it up at the store and it was missing the camera strap. They didn’t have any extra so they gave me a credit which would allow me to buy another strap elsewhere (or use an extra one of my own). They were great. And so far the camera is working wonderfully.

    They did have to refund the original camera and rebuy it at the lower price. Probably lost the portal rebate associated with the original purchase, but that was less than the credit that they gave me.

  • One thing to note about open box items is that they are price-negotiable. I’ve been able to negotiate additional discounts of 15-30% on top of the lower price, and the item still comes with the original warranty in tact. Best Buy is trying to get rid of these items at (almost) any cost. The only ones they are strict on price are the geek-squad certified items. Everything else is fair game.

    • Good point! I have had success with some people, not so much with some other items. The ones I have had more success with are the ones missing boxes, no power cords, things like that.